We Are Change Oklahoma activist James Lane (Photo by Andrew W. Griffin)

UPDATED: We Are Change-OK activists are assaulted, arrested at Penn Square Mall

By - November 29, 2009 9:20 PM

By Andrew W. Griffin

Red Dirt Report, editor

Posted: November 29, 2009

reddirtreporter@gmail.com

OKLAHOMA CITY – Two members of We Are Change Oklahoma claim they were brutally assaulted by mall security guards and an officer of the Oklahoma City Police Department and ultimately arrested on Friday afternoon during a non-violent “street action” at Penn Square Mall.

Red Dirt Report and Oklahoma Watchdog were given exclusive information by Oklahoma City resident and WAC-OK founder and activist James Lane who was just released from the Oklahoma County Jail arrested on charges of assault and battery.

 “Even though I was the victim of the brutal, unprovoked assault, and never touched a single officer, I was charged with assault and battery,” Lane told Red Dirt Report on Sunday evening.

Lane along with fellow activist Brent Southard and a third activist decided to go to Penn Square Mall – owned by Indianapolis-based Simon Property Group - on the afternoon of “Black Friday,” the popular shopping day right after Thanksgiving.

Seeing Penn Square Mall as an optimal place to spread their information via “deception dollars,” which would be tossed from the second floor of the mall in the vicinity of the food court, they hoped to promote alternative media websites.

“There were eight of us initially,” Lane said of the protest which was designed to educate shoppers through the information on the fake money. “We (Lane and Southard) didn’t even throw the dollars.”

Gathering on the second floor, Lane was tasked with photographing the event while Southard held a bag of “deception dollars” and a third activist  announced the action via his bullhorn. This got the attention of mall security who proceeded to first go after the bullhorn-toting third activist but then started going after Southard who held a bag which contained the “deception dollars.”

Lane said Southard fled the scene, exiting near the mall movie theater. It was outside that Southard was ultimately taken down by what Lane considered to be five unprofessional mall security guards.

Meanwhile, Lane said he is close behind his friend, videotaping the entire event as it unfolded. Right before Southard was taken down, he said he heard one guard yell at two other guards to “take ‘em down hard,” immediately prior to his arrest.

Lane said an OCPD officer arrived on foot to assist the guards. All the while, he is about 20 yards from Southard filming this. It is then that Lane said he was approached by three security guards who see him filming the scene. In what he considered to be a threatening manner, they inform Lane to “turn the video camera off.”

Lane said he informed a security guard named Rick Wisner that “the state of Oklahoma is a single consent state and that he can film anywhere and anyone he pleases.” Lane also informs Wisner that he is welcome to ask him to leave mall property but that if he touches him “it will be considered assault.”

This did not stop Wisner and three other security guards from allegedly attacking and assaulting Lane.

As Lane yells that he is being assaulted, he gets the attention of the OCPD officer, yelling to him that “these men are assaulting me.” Instead of intervening and stopping the attack by the guards, the officer allegedly then joins the attack, ordering him to “stop resisting.”

At this point, Lane said his face is pushed into a pile of wood chips on a grass berm, resulting in contusions on his forehead. The assaulting guards and officer allegedly punched Lane in the ribs and back, ordering him to stop resisting. The pressure on his back is so great that Lane said he could not breathe. As he struggles for breath, they allegedly threaten to mace him as well.

Telling one of the assailants to “give him some lung” (air), Lane is able to breathe again but is then handcuffed and arrested.

Sitting in the OCPD squad car, Lane and Southard endure two hours of “snide remarks and veiled threats,” allegedly calling the duo “terrorists” and “ACORN liberals.”

Lane said one of the mall security guards taunted Southard and allegedly said, “You’re going to jail for assault, not me.”  Lane retorts that he will “see him in court.”

Lane and Southard were booked into Oklahoma County Jail in downtown Oklahoma City. The third activist that had been with Lane and Southard fled the mall unmolested.

Lane, now out of jail, is seeking legal help. Information about the WAC-OK legal defense fund can be found at their site – www.wearechangeoklahoma.org.

“Because I was videotaping their actions they brutally attacked me, filed false charges against me and tampered with evidence,” Lane said, adding that he was going to fight the charges.

As for Southard, he was charged with disorderly conduct and assault and battery. He was released as well.

Lane said that the issue regarding “tampered evidence” is that his camera was confiscated as he was taken down and not returned. The police claimed it was being held as evidence.

“I’m 36 years old and I’ve never even been arrested in my life. It was horrible,” Lane said. “We were in lockdown. The jail was on a 72 hour lockdown. Locked two to a cell with lights on and nothing to read or watch. Just sit and stare at the ceiling. Wearing an orange jumpsuit, the whole works.”

Due to the late hour of this report, Red Dirt Report and Oklahoma Watchdog were unable to get comments from Les Morris, public relations officer for the Simon Property Group, or the public information officer for the Oklahoma City Police Department.

UPDATE: November 30, 2009

Red Dirt Report spoke with Sgt. Jennifer Wardlow at the Oklahoma City Police Department. She shared information on a preliminary report she had access to at OCPD. Wardlow confirmed much of the account, except she said that in the report it states that "Lane pushed (the mall security guard) back with one hand on his chest." This would have accounted for the charge of assault and battery. Contacted today by RDR and told of what the preliminary report stated, Lane denied he assaulted the guard. "It never happened." Lane added that the guards were "charging me" and that he may have involuntarily put his hand up to protect himself in a defensive posture. "In no way did I initiate any offensive action against the guard." Wardlow said the final report was not available yet and may be available on Tuesday.

As for Penn Square Mall and comments from their owner, Simon Property Group in Indianapolis, Red Dirt Report spoke with public information officer Les Morris. He had said, earlier in the day, that he would contact the staff at Penn Square. However, when RDR followed up with Morris late Monday afternoon, he curtly responded that "there would be no comment at this point." Asked about mall policy on leafleting on Simon Property Group properties such as Penn Square Mall, Morris again responded with "I don't have any other comment."

Copyright 2009 West Marie Media

Comments:

Please, leave a comment

Only one comment allowed per visit

The Comment and Security Code are required.

Name (optional):
Comment (required):
Enter the code as shown in the image (required): Can't read code?
Why do you need the code?

Excellent Summary Andrew. I helped Brent and James compile the narrative that reveiwed their ordeal. I'm content in knowing that we're on the right side of the law and the right side of history on this event. If not for anything else, legal action will be taken to insure that these 'thugs' will not be able to do this to anyone else here in Oklahoma City in the future. Simon Property Mgmt. will not be happy to learn of the actions of their security staff in this case. They've fallen far short of the professional conduct they claim to uphold. We'll be reviewing this case further on www.ruleoflawradio.com this evening from 8 to 8:30 Pm CST. The radio show call in phone number is: 512.646.1984. Again, GREAT work with the story Andrew ! Regards, Chris E. Co-host - www.radiofreeoklahoma.net
I agree, good story. Someone trying to protect themselves from a thugs charge is accused of assault and battery? Then they get assaulted and thrown in jail and are charged with another misdeameanor for distributing political leaflets. Let me guess, either the camera is "not working anymore", has suddenly dissapeared, or won't be allowed in court. It probably woulnd't matter anyway. What a nice little police state we got ourselves here. F-in fascist pigs!
Thank you for this sad story that sounds like a CYA to me. What a couple of baby’s these two guys are. So these two idiots went to a crowded mall “Black Friday” and threw over the balcony what appeared to be money? I’m glad my mother and grandmother were not trampled or hurt were everyone scrambled for the money. I even heard a lady twisted her ankle in the dash for the fake money. I glad you wrote this article so she knows who to sue.
Im glad this problem is being taken care of, if the mall security beats up people who dont deserve it and writes false reports then they dont need to be security officers. If they get away with this, then who knows who they will beat up next. The right thing to do would have been to simply escort them off the property. We need officers who protect and serve not a gang of thugs in uniform. As for Mike's comment, you need to think about the situation a little more because i think your missing the point, and someone twisting their ankle trying to get "fake money" then that sounds like it their own fault.
Next time you intend to record video in such a situation where you may be assaulted by police, it would be wise to have someone else video recording YOU from a safe distance and out of sight so the police won't know about the second camera. Then, you can either warn them that they are being recorded or just present the second recording when you get to court.
@Mike: "I even heard a lady twisted her ankle in the dash for the fake money". Really? Wow, that's very interesting given that “We (Lane and Southard) didn’t even throw the dollars.”. So who told you about this manic granny who was falling about the place while chasing phantom dollars? Been a shill long? This is disgusting, I hope those security guards and police officer are found guilty of assault in court. Are there cameras in the mall that would of seen anything? Maybe in nearby shops? Thank you so much for your real reporting RDR, I'm glad at least some journalists take their jobs' seriously. Paul French We Are Change Glasgow
I'd like to know the name of this filthy, redneck cop. Anybody? http://www.peoplepowerhour.com
Excellent point Mike. This James Lane guy just wants publicity and is willing to create disturbances and make stupid desicions that could get other people hurt then lie about things to make him look good. I think he needs to find a real job and quit being a baby. And as for the single consent state comment, that does not give you the right to video, photograph or audio tape anyone you want whereever you want, it means that you can record a video/take a photo/ or audio tape a conversation as long as one of the parties involved with the TWO WAY conversation consents to it. You really need to check your facts Mr. Lane. And about the "tampering with evidence"? remark what do you mean tampered with it... the Police probably preserved the evidence to use against you in court... that would be PRESERVING the evidence... and whats the story on the other guy that got booked for assault? how come he's not crying "i'm innocent!" like this Lane guy is?
Hope justice is found as for the 2 people on here talking bout these 2 got what they deserve HUSH NAZI!
We had an interesting run-in with hired goons from the same corporation out here..it happens to be one of the top fortune 500 businesses in America and the #1 real estate owner in the country..heh. I've been trying to get in touch with the WAC OK guys about this but haven't been able to find contact info anywhere.. We're with you guys in spirit. Peace.
you guys are a bunch of dumbass's. Walk into penn square mall at any enterance and see what the rules state. you were on PRIVATE property and broke many of the rules that the mall has Thus giving them the RIGHT to make a citizens arrest. You broke the law now you must do the time. IDIOTS!
Just because people are on private property does not mean that agents of the property owner can assault people because they don’t like what they are doing. It sounds like the security guards should have simply asked these guys to leave the property. Maybe they were showing off in front of the police officers or something. Either way, this reads like a pretty clear case of an excessive use of force. I wonder what the cleet officals will think? Maybe someone should notify them.
TO:anonymous ... So if Penn Square Mall makes a rule against wearing a purple hat they can attack anyone wearing a purple hat and have them thrown in jail? They broke the LAW wearing a purple hat so they get what they deserve? I think you have a flawed opinion of what the "Law" actually is.
you guys dont even know what in the hell you are talking about can you read??? do you read posted signs??? are you stupid??? were you born yesterday??? obviously you were because the sign in the entrances all state the same stuff over and over again when told you cannot yell at people with a megafone you obviously continued and probably started running away to get away and probably knew you werent supposed to be doing this stupid stuff in a mall especially PENN SQUARE to begin with, you dumb ass.... it is not nor ever will be quail springs or crossroads mall you cannot just go in there and do what you want especially throwing any kind of leaflets of any kind... and if you are told to put the camera down (which the rules NOT LAW) specifically forbids to use in the mall, they will and can arrest you, and they can and will take it from you and IF you touch an officer (police or security) during this in any way which stops them from doing this it is considered assault and you will go to jail. Because fool it is private property and either you obey the rules or you will A: leave immediately or B: go to jail especially if a police officer tells you to stop and you refuse to do so.... you people think you can just go to the stupid mall and do whatever and if some stupid security officer tells you to stop you can just ignore him and continue on especially if its something his boss and his bosses boss (the mall manager) tells him to make sure doesnt happen on private property he is required to throw you off property or jail you at his discretion it doesnt matter what you think if you cuss at one of them you can go to jail did you know that?????
HOW MANY OF THESE RULES WERE BROKEN? 1.We Are Change recognizes all members have inalienable rights as sovereign individuals written in the Constitution of the United States and Bill of Rights and that such rights shall be honored at all times 2.No provocation of violence will be tolerated under any circumstances 3.Racial, sexual, religious, age or discrimination of any kind will not be tolerated 4.No group member shall use language in public that will inflame others to violent action 5.No group member shall destroy the property, tangible or intangible, of others, public or private. 6.All members will treat each other with respect at all times 7.Weekly Meetings a.Weekly meetings should be held to discuss and debate any issue pertaining to the group as well as projects and upcoming events b.Only cordial and polite debate about topics shall be discussed and all members with reframe from using profanity to ensure civil discussion is engaged c.All expenditures will be presented to the group with statements presented on the first meeting of every month detailing expenses and money accrued d.Reimbursements for expenses will only be fulfilled if approved by group e.Any persons intoxicated or disrupting will be asked to leave by a majority vote of the group 8.Street Actions a.During street actions, a single engagement of people asking questions will be honored no ganging up on anyone asking questions or seeking information b.Yelling or screaming at members of the public will not be tolerated 9.Cointelpro will not be tolerated a.If anyone is thought to be engaging in such activities a camera shall immediately be put on them, exposing that they are acting as an agent provocateur and an individual not connecting to We Are Change in any way 10.Respect towards FDNY and NYPD a.Derogatory comments disseminated towards NYPD, FDNY or any law enforcement of any kind will not be tolerated 11.We Are Change is a bottom to top organization where all members shall be treated as equals 12.All group members shall strive to set an example for those around them, especially those younger, so they will know how to behave in confrontational situations 13.All members will take responsibility for their own actions and accept the consequences of their actions 14.We Are Change is tolerant of all political viewpoints and does not endorse and particular political group 15.Any persons with a history of any actions that violates the aforementioned policies will be expelled from the organization by a majority vote of the group 16.All footage shot by cameras purchased through We Are Change funds shall be considered property of We Are Change and not of the individual shooting the footage 17.We Are Change does not condone the use of the name without consent of the group
Yeh i can see it now the police show the video in court of you talking on a bullhorn throwing dollar looking leaflets off of the second story food court and when the mall security officer shows up to tell you to quit you cuss him out and start running all the way to the third level garage where one of the officers might yell take em down hard especially if you turn on him and start screaming out your rights to do stupid crap on private property which is disturbing customers around you and start swinging to keep them off of you....BAD MISTAKE!!! And the funniest, stupidest thing about the whole thing that will get YOU busted on this whole mess is, its all on tape... you dumping money and yelling through a bullhorn and then running like the sissy little girls that you are then lying about the whole thing... wow i've now heard it all...isnt that why you want the camera back so you can edit the tape and/or erase it all??? First mistake was taking a camera into the mall and taping everything and then instead of putting down the camera when they said to, you told them to go fly a kite and kept filming so that when they took the camera from you it was all on tape and by the way it has become a mall rule after 9-11 on the use of camera's in the mall but that is because Homeland Security says not to allow any cameras in places that can and might be targeted by terrorists.....
This is completely uncalled for, and I hope an attorney picks this up, files a motion for return of the evidence, and nails the mall and the OKC police department for assault and battery.
you really are an idiot and you will find out real soon what an idiot you really are i have talked to several people that work in the mall and asked one simple question and they all responded the same way that there were several guys up center court that tossed over what appeared to be money and people ran to it so... you need to call your little band of weirdos quits and stop being stupid and get on with your lives cuz boy you dont fool any of us you are lying and ignorant on top of it all lol
The city dropped the assault charges on both of these activists.